Of course, it could also be that josephs plagiarism lifting content from multiple authors, each with their differing writing style fingerprint, would also show differing wordprints in byus analysis. Pdf reassessing authorship of the book of mormon using delta. The spalding enigma by wayne cowdery, howard davis, and donald scales summary. Reassessing authorship of the book of mormon using delta and nearest shrunken centroid classification published in literary and linguistic computing. Book of mormon authorship update from craig criddle page. Jockers, i again see that he is saying that the report published by his research team is only a set of relative authorship attributions. However, does anyone have additional thoughts on the 1982 byu study.
Craig criddle is a professor and senior fellow, woods institute for the environment, stanford university, having taught at stanford since 1998. Lies, expletive deleted lies, and statistics fairmormon. Variations of this theory only include that the text is a divinely inspired narrative, regardless of its. Authorship who really wrote the book of mormon video presentation on the spauldingrigdon theory at the 2009 exmormon foundation conference additional resources. In this second essay, i provide additional evidence supportive of the spaldingrigdon authorship theory, including a response to criticism of the theory. Farnham, travels in the great western prairies, the anahuac and rocky mountains, and in the oregon territory, poughkeepsie, new york. Reassessing authorship of the book of mormon using delta and nearest shrunken centroid classification. Dec 23, 2008 that new book of mormon wordprint study. Ive seen tbms reference this study, numerous times, to argue that joseph smith couldnt have written the book of mormon. The spalding enigma, our authors set out to accomplish a monumental task. For jockers and criddles book of mormon chapter data, it turns out that the absolute probabilities of authorship by spalding or rigdon are, almost without exception, very small.
So says a new computerassisted authorship study out of stanford. The theory first appeared in print in the book mormonism unvailed, published in 1834 by e. Byu scholarsarchive citation roper, matthew and fields, paul j. Ep 27 who wrote the book of mormon part 2 october 14, 20 glenn ostlund 7 comments glenn and randy continue the discussion on who wrote the book of mormon and are joined by dr. Others, however, have assumed that joseph smith or one of his associates wrote it.
Draft preprint of reassessing authorship of the book of mormon. How was the structure of the book of mormon changed after the lostpages incident. Craig criddle s presentation at the exmo conference by randy butterfield on fri oct 30, 2009 12. Openmormon view topic craig criddles presentation at. My article campbellite doctrine in the book of mormon briefly discusses where many of the above doctrines can be found in the book of mormon. I really appreciate a comment by chris spencer on my previous post dueling wordprint studies. Selections from the old book of mormon studies homepage provide unique information and intriguing possibilities. Hiltons methodology thus did not address a key aspect of the book of mormon authorship question. Creating the book of mormon, epaper, originally published 8 october 2005. The forerunner to the book of mormon, manuscript found, was a story penned by solomon spalding. The idea is that sidney rigdon got a hold of the manuscript and used it to author the book of mormon. In the first essay i discussed why authorship of the book of mormon is important, how bias affects the analysis, and i critiqued some of the major authorship theories. Episode 05 provides evidence for how the lost116pages incident triggered a series of events that led to the complexity of the book of mormon.
Craig criddle2009who really wrote the book of mormon. Part of the research includes a wordprint study that attempts to show which chapters in the book of mormon were likely written by rigdon, cowdery, spalding, or parley p. Spaldingrigdon theory of book of mormon authorship wikipedia. Reassessing authorship of the book of mormon using delta. Sidney rigdon embraced mormonism without much investigation. The historical records reveal a small pool of candidate authors collaborating in western new york and northern ohio to create the mormon scriptures. What can stylometry tell us about book of mormon authorship. Theology, cosmology, high priesthood, and temple rites.
Mormonleaks is a research project that seeks to reconstruct the authentic narrative of the origins of the mormon canon by combining macroanalytic computing tools with contemporary historical evidence. Pratt as key players in the authorship of the book of. Oct 14, 20 glenn and randy continue the discussion on who wrote the book of mormon and are joined by dr. Pratt as key players in the authorship of the book of mormon. Examining a misapplication of nearest shrunken centroid. Reassessing authorship of the book of mormon using delta and. Mormon discussions view topic book of mormon authorship. For two years before the book of mormon appeared rigdons sermons were full of declarations and prophecies that the age of miracles would be restored, and more complete revelations, than those in the bible, would be given. Young sidney rigdon seeking fame and fortune through religion. Terryl givens joseph smith would put the seer stone into a hat, and put his face in the hat, drawing it closely around his face to exclude the light. A few weeks ago when i asked about theories of joseph as a savant, i was getting at an image of joseph as a genius, but not a conscious genius. Criddle s investigations contributed to a 2008 wordprint study of the spaldingrigdon claims the results of which were.
We hope you have a wonderful christmas and a happy new year. Criddle does not present his conclusions as offering positive proof of the book s true origins, but instead attempts to track signs authorship through a chronological narrative of the old spaldingrigdon explanation for the book of mormon. Sidney rigdon true author of the book of mormon and. Including all of the words of one of the most repeated signature phrases of the book of mormon as evidenced by mark twains description of it when it is not a feature of spaldings work would be pretty risky if the study was actually a set up. Criddle, the primary inspiration for the study, is a former mormon who has long advocated the theory that sidney rigdon and solomon spalding were the real authors of the book of mormon. Miraculous origins theories generally accept joseph smiths own account, that he translated an ancient record compiled and abridged by mormon, a precolumbian resident of the western hemisphere. Dec 14, 2008 i recently perfunctorily read a new study written by three stanford university professors, titled reassessing authorship of the book of mormon using delta and nearest shrunken centroid classification, and published in the latest issue of the journal, literary and linguistic computing.
Jun 18, 2015 when i first started investigating how the book of mormon was written, i thought this theory was compelling. Supplementary data for reassessing authorship of the book of. And to do that, the only concrete thing you have to base that on is the roman story mswhich you apparently think works in your favor. Book of mormon authorship update from craig criddle the catchall forum for general topics and debates. The battle over mormonleaks two websites with one name and one goal. Quotes joseph used a peep stone and a hat to translate most of the book of mormon. He maintained this in spite of extensive problems with the theory that has led some critics of the book of mormon to abandon this theory as hopeless.
When the book of mormon appeared, all who heard him were satisfied that he referred to it. The spaldingrigdon theory of book of mormon authorship is the theory that the book of mormon was plagiarized in part from an unpublished manuscript written by solomon spalding. Choosing the best of an woefully incomplete list tells the reader nothing about who really wrote the book of mormon the stanford authors clucking agreement with the authors of the book by that name notwithstandingjust as not checking out all. Ep 27 who wrote the book of mormon part 2 infants on thrones. Book of mormon authorship update from craig criddle. While i admit to being disturbed by the article, it is not for. At best, one might hope to conclude from such an analysis that the chosen selections are not by the same author, but the methodology used does not exclude the possibility of multiple nineteenth century authors. Robertss study which was published posthumously in 1985 as studies of the book of mormon.
In that post, i had discussed a controversial study completed by stanford researchers mathew jockers, daniela witten, and craig criddle who concluded that 57% the book of mormon was authored by sidney rigdon and solomon spaulding. Craig criddle, a professor at stanford university who believes the book of mormon had several authors. I also summarized 24 pieces of evidence, pointing to sidney rigdon as a key contributor and likely mastermind for the 1830 version of the book of mormon. Prior to 2008, no published authorship study results linked sidney rigdon to writing of the book of mormon. The research is interesting, but it looks like theres a. Craig criddle s address at the ex mormon foundation october 2009. Dec 12, 2017 since the book of mormons publication in 1830, a number of different theories have been proposed concerning its authorship.
Witnesses described it as a biblicalstyle fiction that traced the origin of native americans to migrations from the middle east. Spalding submitted his manuscript to a pittsburgh print shop for publication. Jan 19, 2011 a year or two ago, the oxford university press journal literary and linguistic computing published a statistical argument for the spalding theory of book of mormon authorship. Turning to the object of the paper written by schaalje et al. In this second essay, i provide additional evidence supportive of the spaldingrigdon authorship theory, including a response to. Also, since i gave the exmo conference talk in october, we have retested the book of mormon, including this new material as a signal for smith. Dec 09, 2008 a new wordprint study on the book of mormon breathes new life to a longchallenged theory for book of mormon authorship, the theory that its real author was solomon spalding secretly assisted by sidney rigdon.
In 2008, matthew jockers, daniela witten, and craig criddle applied two statistical methodsdelta and nearest shrunken centroid classification nscto the question of book of mormon authorship. The historical case against sidney rigdons authorship of the book of mormon. D, is a professor and senior fellow, woods institute for the environment, stanford university. Criticism of mormonismbookswho really wrote the book of mormon. Craig criddle evidence of rigdons involvement with the book of mormon manuscript. The deliberate archaic language of the book of mormon may have something to do with this, but that was not anything discussed by jockers and criddle. Book of mormon, until pratt and cowdery handed it to him for inspection.
A new wordprint study on the book of mormon breathes new life to a longchallenged theory for book of mormon authorship, the theory that its real author was solomon spalding secretly assisted by sidney rigdon. The goal was to offer the public new evidence that the book of mormon, the churchs foundational scripture, was not an ancient record translated. Since the book of mormons publication in 1830, a number of different theories have been proposed concerning its authorship. The historical case against sidney rigdons authorship of. This new analysis continues to indicate that the major authors were rigdon and spalding. Feb 19, 2010 the inclusion of all the words is yet another indicator of the robustness of the findings. Daniela witten, and craig criddle who concluded that 57% the book of mormon was authored by sidney rigdon and solomon spaulding. See jockers, witten, criddle, reassessing authorship of the book of mormon, 482. The history of sidney rigdon the history of joseph smith. Although criddle s lecture is accompanied by numerous examples of relevent evidence, it is a. November 27, 2017 what can stylometry tell us about book of. The historical case against sidney rigdons authorship of the. This project is the result of painstaking effort on the part of matt jockers, daniela m. By craig criddle email the author sidney rigdon elder sidney.
Spaldingrigdon theory of book of mormon authorship. In addition, because professor criddle has been involved in efforts to resuscitate the spaldingrigdon theory of book of mormon authorship, roper and fields were also invited to comment on that rather moribund explanation in a separate essay that immediately follows this one. The battle over mormonleaks two websites with one name. There are differing views on the origin of the book of mormon. This theory says much of the story of the book of mormon was plagiarized from an unpublished manuscript written by solomon spalding.
Examining a misapplication of nearest shrucnken centroid. Response to claims made in who really wrote the book of mormon. The discussion centers around the spaldingrigdon theory of book of mormon authorship. What has rarely been addressed is that for much of. This book attempted to revive the moribund spalding manuscript theory for the book of mormon. Craig criddles address at the exmormon foundation october 2009.
Campbellite doctrine in the book of mormon beggars bread. A primary takeaway seems to be that wordprint analysis is an imprecise tool for determining authorship of the book of mormon. While it has not received anywhere near the attention that i had expected it to receive, a few critics have seen it as th. But yes, you, on the other hand, wish to reject what they point blank tell you. Who wrote the book of mormon part 2 infants on thrones. Wordprint analysis and the book of mormon deseret news. Craig criddle part 1 part 1 of craig criddle s 2009 ex mormon conference presentation. Craig criddle part 2 part 2 of craig criddle s 2009 ex mormon conference.
1377 418 1256 809 1042 1151 254 858 245 964 732 573 430 259 1247 1470 169 902 1524 1527 617 1455 1205 16 1188 1236 67 280 376 1329 437 694 1304